The Rise and (Impending?) Fall of the Chief Digital Officer

The Rise and (Impending?) Fall of the Chief Digital Officer

By Mike Doonan, Partner, SPMB

Mike Doonan, Partner, SPMB

Large corporate enterprises are under enormous pressure from customers and investors to transform themselves into something more interesting and valuable than they are today. Every industry vertical—from retail and telecom to energy and media — is being disintermediated by nimble up-and-comers through the application of new business models and technology.

There's been a lot of talk in the press and the board room about large companies driving dramatic “transformations” in order to stay relevant and compete in the global markets. Many in the media have referred to this as “going digital,” but what does that really mean? Going digital can mean many things to many people. To me, it can mean two very distinct things, which in and of itself creates confusion. I define it as either creating a new digital channel, or, evolving a company’s business model through the implementation of technology and/or process change.

Some companies see going digital as adding a new channel to an existing business model. The retail channel is the most obvious case study here, given that we are all consumers. In order to compete in the world of, incumbent retailers have gone external for talent to help them bring e-commerce channels to market. Companies like, for example, have created entirely new companies with the goal of making sure the mothership does not impede innovation.

“Going Digital” as a Transformational Tool

The more revolutionary definition of “going digital” is what I affectionately refer to as “doing digital for the brave.” It’s when an organization embarks on a company-wide initiative that leverages technology to drive cross-channel transformational change. Typically led by a Chief Digital or Chief Transformation Officer, companies will pursue a digital transformation path in an effort to:

1) increase revenue
2) decrease cost
3) remove friction from internal systems, and/or
4) enable a new or enhance an existing end user consumption model.

This last point is the big payoff for companies. It is the the one that really allows a company to “break the chains” of an existing business model that are dragging its products or services into commoditization and obscurity. But it also comes with the biggest risk.

If you are a company that has decided to take the plunge and go the digital transformation route, good for you. You are now on your way to the land of milk and honey. But beware of the landmines that lie ahead. One of the most fatal mistakes occurs the minute you hire an executive search firm to find your Chief Digital Officer.

Executive Search’s Dirty Little Secret

Many firms specialize in recruiting Chief Digital Officers - my firm included. Those in our industry fight hand over fist to win these opportunities, especially if it’s for a major public company. And because the incentive to win the search supersedes all else, most executive search firms take the project without determining if a Chief Digital Officer hire even makes sense for the company.

In the interest of hitting a revenue target, executive search firms will sidestep the true diligence stage and avoid asking the really hard questions that will determine the type of Chief Digital Officer that will take a company where it needs to go.

When I am asked to do a Chief Digital Officer search, I will not take the project on until I have spent a significant amount of time with the company trying to figure out what problem they are trying to solve. By doing so, I am able to uncover the following:

 • You don’t need a Chief Digital Officer

The main role of a CIO - is to create a frictionless consumption model for products and services, both internally and externally. If you have achieved this outcome, pat yourself on the back and skip hiring a Chief Digital Officer. You are already a digitally inclined organization (whether or not you can spell digital.)  But if you have a CIO that is only about keeping the lights on, then you really don’t even have a CIO - you have a VP of IT. And if that’s the case, then you are really in trouble. So hiring a Chief Digital Officer in this case is probably a good option for you.

 • You have a Chief Digital Officer, but don’t know it

So often, I find that a company already has someone to lead a digital transformation, but this individual is buried within marketing or strategy. 30 minutes in front of a white board, and I am generally able to find this person and save a company from paying me a hefty search fee.

 • You’re hiring a Chief Digital Officer because it’s trendy

You have not fully hashed out the problem you are trying to solve. Many CEOs look at industry leaders and when they see that a perceived “hot” company has a Chief Digital Officer, they say “I want one of those.”  This could be perhaps the worst reason to start a search for a Chief Digital Officer.  Unfortunately, I see this all the time.

The End of the Chief Digital Officer?

If the current hiring trend by executive search firms continues, Chief Digital Officer will become the scapegoats for failed digital transformation initiatives, and could very well be removed from the IT staffing structure altogether.

If I could offer up one take away to companies pursuing digital transformation, it would be this - slow down and take stock of what you really need. Just because company A has a Chief Digital Officer doesn’t mean you need one too. And if you find an executive search firm that says “yes” to filling your Chief Digital Officer request before pausing to ask you the tough questions, you should run in the opposite direction. It may be the most cost-saving sprint you’ll ever do.

Weekly Brief

Top 10 Employee Engagement Solution Companies - 2020
Top 10 Employee Engagement Consulting/Service Companies – 2020